Ten Sturdy Members: The Military Police of the 18th Battalion

Two photographs have striking similarities. The men are uniformed and look seriously, almost in admonishment, at the camera. Five hold swagger sticks and most of the men sport moustaches. If not for the captions on the photographs the sleeve brassards at the bottom left-hand jacket sleeve cuff would indicate what they all shared in common – they were members of the military police.

London Free Press. December 1914.
London Advertiser. February 15, 1915. Page 1.

They were not formal members of the Provost Corps, or its Canadian equivalent, but had been tasked with the responsibilities of military good order and conduct at a battalion level, in this case the 18th Battalion, CEF, stationed and training at London, Ontario during October 1914 to April 1915.

Though the quality of each photograph is not optimal, it can be derived that these men were, most of them, older than the average recruit at enlistment. But this was the defining reason for their assignment to this role. They averaged 32.5-years in age. It was not their average height (5’ 7”) or weight (159 lbs.) that defined their role. Their trade or calling seemed to have not determining influence as just over half (55%) were skilled or semi-skilled in peacetime. And, finally, it was not their place of birth that determined this (83% United Kingdom born)[i].

What probably did define their suitability for this role was their prior military service. All these men served with military units before their enlistment. The average years of service was 8.2 years and only one soldier was soldier[ii] served in only a militia unit, and probably as a drummer, as every other soldier served with line units during their prior military service.

Of the eleven men identified in the photographs, 75% survived the war. Of those that did not, two were killed in action (Privates Thomas William Dobson, reg. no. 53669 and Arthur Jefferies, reg. no. 54129). The second oldest member of the military police, Private Alfred Charles Aldersley, reg. no. 53077 dying from complications related to cancer of the bladder.

From the news paper clippings and articles of that time, the London Free Press and Advocate related some significant events that would have involved these men:

It appears that once the Battalion moved into West Sandling on its arrival in England for the next stage of training this role was no longer required and was taken over by the Assistant Provost Marshall, 2nd Division. There the Battalion had its share of run-ins with the law, recording the highest incident of soldiers absent without out leave in its Brigade realizing 38 men AWL out of a total of 58 cases as reported on July 18, 1915.

These men were tapped for a duty of responsibility for their experience from their military service. They look stalwart and firm and helped the 18th Battalion maintain good order and conduct during its service in London during its nascent experience as a military unit brought together by the exigencies of war.

The Data: Some tables representing the background to this article.

Country of Birth and Trade

Surname Forename Reg. No. Country Trade
Aldersley Alfred Charles 53077 England Labourer
Clarke Albert Edward 53091 England Hosiery Hand
DobsonThomas Williams Thomas Williams 53669 England Farm Labourer
Evans George 54122 Canada Moulder
Hare David 53344 Ireland Pipe Fitter
Hatch Henry 53120 England Labourer
Hodgson James 53076 Ireland Labourer
Jefferies Arthur 54129 England Teamster
Manning William 53935 England Cabinet Maker
Robins Alfred 53614 England Labourer
Windle Arthur 53295 Canada Box Maker
83% from UK 55% Skilled/Semi-Skilled


Military Unit and Total Years of Military Service

Surname Forename Previous Service Years Age
Aldersley Alfred Charles Rifle Brigade 16 38.25
Clarke Albert Edward Leicestershire Regiment 7 38.75
Dobson Thomas Williams Royal Horse Artillery 12 34
Evans George 38th Dufferin Rifles 6 20.5
Hare David Royal Irish Rifles, 7th Regiment 12.1 38.1
Hatch Henry Gloucestershire Regiment 8 27.9
Hodgson James West Yorkshire Regiment 8.25 29.25
Jefferies Arthur 12th Yorkshire, 36th Regiment 3 25.75
Manning William 2nd Northhampshire 30
Robins Alfred 8th Company, Garrison Artillery 8 35.2
Windle Arthur Royal Rifles of Canada 2 39.25
Average 8.2 32.5
Minimum 2 20.5
Maximum 16 39.25


Physical Attributes[iii]

Aldersley Alfred Charles 53077 38.25 64
Clarke Albert Edward 53091 38.75 64
Dobson Thomas Williams 53669 34 68.5
Evans George 54122 20.5 70 184
Hare David 53344 38.1 67
Hatch Henry 53120 27.9 67 165
Hodgson James 53076 29.25 66
Jefferies Authur 54129 25.75 68.5
Manning William 53935 30 65.5 150
Robins Alfred 53614 35.2 67.5 136
Windle Arthur 53295 39.25 68
32.5 66.9 158.8
Minimum 20.5 64 136
Maximum 39.25 70 184




Surname Forename Reg. No. Survived Deceased Cause
Aldersley Alfred Charles 53077 No 22/8/1915 DOI
Clarke Albert Edward 53091 Yes
Dobson Thomas Williams 53669 No 17/7/1916 KIA
Evans George 54122 Yes 10/1/1955
Hare David 53344 Yes
Hatch Henry 53120 Yes
Hodgson James 53076 Yes 11/8/1952
Jefferies Authur 54129 No 15/9/1916 KIA
Manning William 53935 Yes
Robins Alfred 53614 Yes
Windle Arthur 53295 Yes 31/10/1933
75% Survived


[i] The two Canadian born members where from Brantford, Ontario. Brantford was not normally a town from which recruits for the 18th Battalion came from. These were Private George Evans, reg. no. 54122, and Private Arthur Windle, reg. no. 53295. They enlisted at London and Windsor, Ontario respectively.

[ii] Private George Evans, reg. no. 54122 enlisted at the age of 20 with 6-years of prior military service with the 38th Dufferin Rifles.

[iii] Note that height is measured in inches.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: